Why You Should Consider Selling Your Mutual Funds

by Hank Coleman

There are many reasons to sell mutual funds.I am a buy and hold investor. I do not like to sell many of my investments. I’m decades away from retiring, and I’m a long-term investor to say the least. It takes a lot for me to sell mutual funds that I own. But, I have been known to transfer the assets from one mutual fund or mutual fund company to another one based on certain criteria. There are times that it is best to just sell your mutual funds and let them go. Things change. Investing philosophies and goals change. Those are the reason to sell mutual funds.

Four Reasons To Sell Mutual Funds

Fund Manger Changes Direction

You purchase a mutual fund based on its fund manager and the fund company’s investing philosophy and their stated agenda. Sometimes fund managers start deviating from their investing strategy based on conditions in the market and what is working. It is called style drift when a manager starts sliding away from their original investment’s intent. Maybe your international mutual fund is started to drift into a global type mutual fund. Maybe your large capitalization mutual fund has started buying smaller cap stocks. You should continue to monitor your mutual funds performance and also read its prospectus to find out if its investing philosophy is changing over time.

Portfolio Rebalancing

One great reason that most people sell mutual funds is to rebalance their investment portfolio. Now is a great time to consider rebalancing your portfolio of investments. Most financial experts and planners recommend rebalancing your portfolio at least once per year to keep your asset allocation in check. Maybe you have one type of mutual fund category in your portfolio has done better than others. Now you can have too much of your investment allocation over weighted in one category over another. So, portfolio rebalancing is a reason to sell a mutual fund.

Mutual Fund Changes Managers

Another reason that many investors sell mutual funds is that a fund manager changes. Like any company, things change when a manager or leader of the mutual fund changes. You should give extra credence to fund managers who have been running their mutual funds for a long period of time. It does not do much good if you pick a mutual fund with a great 10 year track record of stellar returns and a brand new fund manager that didn’t help the fund get those great rates of return.

Ultimate Checklist for Your Finances

Take back control of your finances!

Get a FREE checklist for the money moves to make in the New Year.

Also get new articles, advice, and tips delivered right in your email inbox with our newsletter!

Changes In Your Life

We all know that you are supposed to transition out of risky investments later in life as you near retirement age. You should also start to transition to safer investments such as bonds, certificates of deposit, and cash equivalents as you get closer towards your investing goals. You may find yourself needing to sell mutual funds and transfer the funds into new, safer investments as you get closer to events such as retirement or your children entering into college for example.

Sell Mutual Funds In Retirement Accounts

I am very hesitant to tell someone to sell a mutual fund that is part of his or her retirement accounts, Roth IRAs or 401k retirement plan. But, you shouldn’t be hemmed into a poor investment if it is not working out for you though either. Instead consider conducting a direct transfer into another retirement account. You can call the mutual fund company and set it up with a simple piece of paperwork. Conducting a direct transfer will save you from being penalized by the IRS for making an early withdrawal. Many investors take the funds out of their retirement accounts and have a check sent directly to them. They often fail to deposit it immediately into a new retirement account. There is a short time limit that you have to deposit the money into a new account before you get hit with a penalty. A direct rollover or a direct transfer from mutual fund company to fund company can help you avoid a needless penalty.

Are there other reasons that you sell mutual funds in your investment portfolio? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comment section.

Open a Lending Club IRA and boost your retirement

About Hank Coleman

Hank Coleman is the founder of Money Q&A, an Iraq combat veteran, a Dr. Pepper addict, and a self-proclaimed investing junkie. He has written extensively for many nationally known financial websites and publications. Hank holds a Master’s Degree in Finance and a graduate certificate in personal financial planning. Email him directly at Hank[at]MoneyQandA.com.


Hank Coleman has written 585 articles on Money Q&A. Learn more about Money Q&A on Twitter @MoneyQandA and @HankColeman.


Subscribe To Money Q&A

If you want to learn more about taking back control of your money please subscribe to Money Q&A’s RSS feed or via email to receive all the latest articles! You can also subscribe to our Free Weekly Newsletter.

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

John S @ Frugal Rules

Great points. I am not a tried and true buy and holder, but I do lean that way. You basically covered it, but a key thing I look for is wacky turnover with the managers. If they’re changing regularly, then it makes me wonder how exactly they’re managing my money too with so much change.

Reply

Money Beagle

I agree. One other reason would be if the mutual fund fees are excessive. If your fund is charging 1.2% and there is another fund available that matches or beats the return and has the same investment goals, with a fee of 0.8%, then it’s worth the consideration to switch. A 0.4% difference may not seem like a lot but if you have a fund that averages a 8% gain, that’s 5% of your profit being wiped out on an annual basis with a higher fee fund.

Reply

WorkSaveLive

I think if a fund is majorly under-performing for consecutive years then you should consider selling it. Furthermore, if you chose your funds with no real reasoning or education behind the decision, then it’s not a bad idea to get professional advice and sell the funds the advisor suggests.

The fund manager ones are big though and it’s hard to stay on top of that…although it’s extremely important and I don’t believe most novice investors realize how big of an impact that may have on a mutual fund.

Reply

Sean @ One Smart Dollar

If Obama is re-elected I am going to be thinking about selling a lot of my long term positions to make sure I am taxed at 15% since he will most likely raise capital gains tax.

Reply

Crystal @ Get A Copywriter

Good points. I have found that my target date mutual funds rebalance like I would anyway, so overall, I am not selling right now. But if I ever see something happening that I don’t agree with, I’m out.

Reply

chandan

good points its really a difficult phase and i am thinking to sell some of my mutual funds in coming months ….thanks for these tips

Reply

Leave a Comment


Previous post:

Next post: