How I Am Struggling As An Accidental Landlord For The First Time

by Hank Coleman

Accidental LandlordsLast year, my wife and I joined the league of accidental landlords. We were upside down in our home and couldn’t sell it without taking a big loss. So after relocating for work, we decided to rent our house out.

I thought it would be a simple endeavor to charge enough rent in order to cover our mortgage payment each month. But that was hardly the case when the rubber met the road. There were several important factors I neglected to take into consideration that hampered my return. I was struggling just to break even.

With a mortgage payment of $1,400 a month, there are many things that took a bite out of my renter’s payment. Forget making a profit; I was struggling just to break even.

Nickeled and Dimed by the Little Things

Because I now live several states away from my home, I had to hire a property manager to manage the house, advertise, screen and find tenants for me. Most property management firms charge a fee equal to 10 percent of the monthly rent. So, for example, charging $1,500 in rent costs me $150 each month for the property manager. If I charged that amount in rent, I’d already be taking a loss on my mortgage.

Ultimate Checklist for Your Finances

Take back control of your finances!

Get a FREE checklist for the money moves to make in the New Year.

Also get new articles, advice, and tips delivered right in your email inbox with our newsletter!

Of course, it hasn’t been all sweetness and light. After about a year as a landlord, I’ve already encountered maintenance and vacancy issues when my first tenants moved out. Most first-time landlords, myself included, fail to include enough money as a cushion to ride out the hiccups. I failed at first to include maintenance costs and the vacancy factor into the rent equation.

Maintenance Costs and Vacancies Can Compound the Problem

To help prevent my monthly maintenance costs from skyrocketing, I decided to purchase a home warranty, which cost me another $40 a month. Of course, I hadn’t factored that into the rent my tenants paid. Last summer,

I also had to file a claim against my home warranty for a $600 air conditioner part that wasn’t covered.

Many experts recommend including a vacancy factor of at least 10 percent in the amount of rent charged. So, in my case, I could expect at least 30 to 60 days of vacancy every time I had to find a new tenant. To help protect my costs and build a buffer fund, I needed to charge at least 8 percent to 10 percent more in rent or else I wouldn’t be able to cover my monthly mortgage payment.

Rent: A Game of Supply and Demand

Our first tenants moved out after a year, and we simply relisted the house at the same price. But we failed to take into account that comparable rents in our neighborhood had declined. It was a renters market.

Three months and two rent price decreases later, my wife and I finally found a new tenant. But the new tenants were paying almost 15 percent to 20 percent less than the previous ones. The fact that we were barely breaking even before pushed our personal profit and loss statement to the breaking point. We definitely weren’t breaking even now with all the added costs and the decreased rent.

As landlords, we no longer had any pricing power on our rent. To make matters worse, we missed the refinancing window to lower our monthly mortgage payments. So if you’re ever thinking about becoming an accidental landlord, it’s best to refinance your home while you’re still living in it. Or you have to have at least a 20 percent equity stake in it because the bank now considers it an investment property if you don’t live there.

To say that my wife and I learned the hard way about being landlords is an understatement. For more than a year now, we’ve routinely had a negative monthly cash flow of over $150 on our rent income. It’s not enough to cover our mortgage payments. We’ve basically been subsidizing our tenants’ rent each month.

I guess it’s true what they say about major purchases: The way to make the most money isn’t when you sell the property. The profit comes when you save money making the purchase. The same was true for us. Because we didn’t refinance or seriously consider all the costs of becoming a landlord, we pay for it every month. It’s a death by a thousand cuts.

Have you ever tried your hand at being a landlord? Were you surprised at how many little costs ate away at your profit margin each month?

Note: This article originally appeared on AOL Daily Finance and is reprinted with permission. See the full article on AOL Daily Finance.

myFICO Score Watch Trial

About Hank Coleman

Hank Coleman is the founder of Money Q&A, an Iraq combat veteran, a Dr. Pepper addict, and a self-proclaimed investing junkie. He has written extensively for many nationally known financial websites and publications. Hank holds a Master’s Degree in Finance and a graduate certificate in personal financial planning. Email him directly at Hank[at]

Hank Coleman has written 581 articles on Money Q&A. Learn more about Money Q&A on Twitter @MoneyQandA and @HankColeman.

Subscribe To Money Q&A

If you want to learn more about taking back control of your money please subscribe to Money Q&A’s RSS feed or via email to receive all the latest articles! You can also subscribe to our Free Weekly Newsletter.

{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }

Kevin @ Credit Bureau Insider

I was also an accidental landlord for about ten years. I bought a condo during a real estate boom cycle. When the time came to upgrade to a house I owed more on the mortgage than the unit was worth.

The rent did not cover my monthly expenses either. However we were able to deduct depreciation on the unit as a business expense, along with other maintenance and management fees. We showed a loss on the property every year, reducing our tax bill.

The unit was eventually sold for a little more than was owed on the mortgage.


Bryce @ Save and Conquer

Sorry to hear you’re in this pickle. Unfortunately, I don’t have any good answers for you. You can only charge what the market will bear. How much of a loss would you take if you sell the house? It may be better to just take a single large loss than the current death by a thousand cuts. Perhaps you could work out a short sale with no recourse with the bank and a possible buyer.


Matt Costigan

What about the part of the mortgage payment that is principal? Unless the home is going down in value, or you have an interest only loan, you are gaining equity by paying down principal and hopefully some appreciation in the property. Not to mention the real estate loss the other commentors mentioned. If your income is too high to take a taxable loss on residential rental real estate, you’ll get the accumulated loss the year you dispose of the property.


Alicia @ Financial Diffraction

*raises hand* count me in the accidental landlord club. We have only been at it for nine months, but so far so good. We rent to my brother-in-law and his family, and my father (lives 20 minutes away) is a very handy man that will do any small maintenance project.

We’re able to build a small slush fund of $175/month, but it’s helping cushion any unexpected expenses. Hopefully it keeps going well, and only costs me a bottle of wine every once and awhile to my Dad 🙂


Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: